Showing posts with label Myers Briggs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Myers Briggs. Show all posts

Friday, 8 April 2016

MBTI: HOW TO TYPE SUPERHEROES




Comic books differ from other art forms - novels, plays, TV shows, movies - and we are faced with a different set of problems when typing a comic book character as opposed to one in a TV show.

When typing characters on a TV show such as Bold and the Beautiful, it's best to proceed as follows: get to know the 16 types and their little quirks and foibles really well and then attempt to recognise such-and-such a character as a typical instance of a certain type as seen in a TV show, comic book or movie.

On TV, character - and MBTI - is revealed to us in flashes: TV shows give us little pieces of a character at a time (from which we can divine a character's type). TV shows (and movies) can trace their forebear to the play, which is the oldest dramatic art form, and plays (according to Aristotle) only show slices of a character - not all of a character's life, only the most important moments of the character's life.

While comic books portray slices of life, comic book characters - especially superheroes and supervillains - reveal their type to us not only through their personality traits but their powers and abilities. As we shall see, some superpowers are more suited to an Intuitive type than a Sensor and vice versa.

If you cast your mind back to the superhero role-playing and card games of the 1980s and 1990s, you'll recall that usually each character's statistics reflect their strengths and weaknesses in certain areas. One of Superman's weaknesses lies in the field of the supernatural and magic, while Doctor Strange (as 'Earth's Sorcerer Supreme') exhibits mastery in that domain; the Silver Surfer possess the 'Power Cosmic', and is classified (along with Adam Warlock, Thanos, Galactus and Captain Marvel) in the Heroclix game series as a 'cosmic', while Spiderman doesn't show any propensity towards the 'cosmic' at all. One of my arguments here in this article is that these dichotomies - supernatural versus scientific, cosmic versus earthbound and others like them - bear upon MBTI and socionics.

I. Sensor or Intuitive?




We can define that dichotomy - Sensors versus Intuitives - in superhero land as being one of brains versus brawn. Characters whose powers and abilities tend to be mental (e.g., telepathic) or supernatural more often than not should be classified as Intuitives; so should characters whose ability (as opposed to superpower) could be said to be mental and intellectual (perhaps the character is a detective or a scientist) or consisting of some intangible quality such as 'charisma' or 'leadership'. On the other hand, Sensors will have, more often than not, a main power or ability based on strength, force and the use of weaponry; sometimes they will possess enhanced 'super-senses' (e.g., Wolverine, Daredevil). Intuitives tend to dwell in the mental or spiritual realm, Sensors in the material and sensory.

Take a look at some of the X-Men from the Chris Claremont years. Jean Grey, Professor X, Nightcrawler, Storm, Kitty Pryde, Longshot, Beast belong in the Intuitive category; Cyclops, Wolverine, Colossus, Rogue in the Sensor. Remember that Cyclops' main ability is to blast things with force beams from his eyes - force blasts, force bolts, the power to construct energy barriers and shields ('force manipulation') are a Sensor's power. Storm's power (weather control) and Nightcrawler's (teleportation) require a mental effort as opposed to the physical; or, to put it another way, an effort of thought as opposed to an effort of will. You could say that Nightcrawler must use intuition - extraverted intuition, Ne - to avoid teleporting ('bampfing' as he calls it) into the wrong place.



A character can start out as a Sensor and transform into an Intuitive, or vice versa. In her first appearance in an Avengers annual, Rogue plays the role of villain with the ability to siphon off or steal the super-powers and characteristics of superheroes - which, at first sight, makes her seem an Intuitive. But, after she steals Ms Marvel's powers and becomes an X-Men regular - and it's in that series that we get to know her - she becomes super-strong, super-fast, invulnerable; in short, she becomes a Sensor. Likewise, the Beast may seem to be a Sensor, but we mustn't forget that before he became a mutant he was Hank McCoy, a super-scientist, and, like Tony Stark / Iron Man, a rather extraverted and loquacious one at that. The fact that such an obvious Intuitive winds up as having the superpowers of a Sensor represents an intended irony; we find the same irony at work in Spiderman, a geeky and nerdy Intuitive who becomes super-strong.

In the Fantastic Four, we find two Sensors, two Intuitives. Mister Fantastic, as we know, can stretch, turn himself into rubber balls and all sorts of things, but let's remember the defining trait of the character (which made itself felt even before he gained superpowers): he's a brilliant inventor and scientist. That makes him an Intuitive... Like Green Lantern, Invisible Woman can construct invisible force-fields and objects which can be used as battering rams, etc., but these abilities were a later addition. Originally she was known for being able to turn herself (and objects and other people) invisible: more of a mental power than a physical. In contrast, the Thing owns a rocky and impervious body and can lift huge objects. This, to me, makes him a Sensor, and, what's more, can be related back to introverted sensing Si, which, as we know, involves physical strength, physical toughness and self-discipline. As for the Human Torch, his powers manifest themselves in the physical realm in a spectacular way. He blazes fire trails through the sky, makes and throws fireballs, overheats and blows up robots and machines, goes supernova... These demonstrate force, will, and force and will imposed on others - extraverted sensing Se.

In the case of the 'A-list' of DC characters, we find Sensor heroes Superman, Green Lantern, Green Arrow, the Flash and Intuitive heroes Batman, Robin and Wonder Woman. Green Lantern uses will power to make objects with his power ring, the Flash uses super speed to make his body a weapon (able to saw through objects or burn them up using friction, for example) - powers which are based on the sensory and the physical. Batman and Dick Grayson use their mental abilities to do detective work (as does Sherlock Holmes, another Intuitive) and are escape artists (like Mister Miracle, an Intuitive). Wonder Woman, as we know, can lift heavy objects, which should make her a Sensor, but I argue that an intangible quality - moral leadership or charisma - makes up her main ability, an ability she shares with Dick Grayson / Nightwing. Taylor types both Grayson and Wonder Woman as ENFJs, and ENFJ super-characters usually display an intangible, intuitive ability to lead and inspire (and manipulate).

We know that Magneto, Darkseid and Namor the Sub-Mariner possess all sorts of powers, but, if we're to trace back a main, or prime ability in these three, it's the ability to lead (or inspire fear in) men. The same goes for other Intuitive leader-types the Kingpin, the Red Skull and Loki.



The lesson is that we must always look at the fundamentals. In the case of the Spectre, we could be forgiven for thinking that he'd be an Intuitive like so many other Marvel and DC supernatural characters - e.g., the Phantom Stranger or Doctor Strange. But if you've read any of the Spectre comic books, it becomes clear early on that he's an ISTJ - a Sensor. That's because the character started out as an ISTJ: he's a police detective, Lieutenant Jim Corrigan, who comes back to life after being murdered by criminals as a vengeance-driven spook. That theme - the ISTJ as a vengeful supernatural entity - appears again and again in horror. Likewise, Boston Brand / Deadman, before being murdered, is a circus performer and a Sensor; ironically, he becomes transformed, after death, into a character with superpowers we normally associate with Intuitives - he turns into a ghost who can take over people's bodies.



I'll note here in passing that Sensors, particularly the extraverted-sensing ones, seem to be drawn to the use of weapons. Think of Daredevil (billy clubs), James Bond (handguns), Wolverine (claws), Elektra (sai daggers), Deathstroke the Terminator (swords and staves), Valkyrie from the Defenders (swords)... The archer characters spring to mind here also: both Oliver Queen / Green Arrow and Hawkeye are Sensors and both use bows and arrows. All these characters display an uncanny virtuosity when using their weapon of choice.



II. Thinker or Feeler?


Thinking and feeling make up, in socionics and MBTI, the two judging or 'Rational' functions. We make value judgements using either thinking or feeling, as do comic book characters. Dialogue and interplay gives us a fairly good idea of how a character will react to a certain situation and what value judgements they will make.

We see that in the famous Green Lantern and Green Arrow team-up stories by Neal Adams and Denny O'Neil . When confronted with an ethical dilemma, Green Lantern - as a Thinker - will consult the law: he asks himself, 'How does this look objectively and from the standpoint of accepted rules, morals, manners and customs?'. Green Arrow, on the other hand, will emote straight away. He reacts, instantly, and gives his interpretation - based on his own deeply-held moral convictions.

In the comic books, thinker characters tend to be  logical, detached, rational - but not always more intelligent - and calculating; if they don't possess much in the way of morals, they'll use deception if need be. Feelers, on the other hand, show an absence of guile and often find it difficult to detach themselves from their emotions and look at things objectively. Extraverted feeling revolves around what others feel and what their opinions, morals, habits are; introverted feeling, one's own moral evaluations and emotional reactions. A catchphrase of an extraverted Feeler superhero such as Superman is, 'Don't do that - it will hurt other people' ; for an introverted Feeler, 'Don't do that, because I don't like it'. Whereas, for extraverted thinkers such as the Punisher and Batman, things may be prohibited because they are unjust and go against The Law with a capital L -  a higher law than that of the America criminal justice system.

In the X-Men, Wolverine, Cyclops, Storm, Beast number among the rational and calculating types, whereas Professor X, Jean Grey, Nightcrawler, Colossus, Rogue, Kitty Pryde should be thought of as Feelers. The difference is illustrated by the contrast between Magneto and Professor X. Magneto, being a Thinker, looks at events from a calculating and technocratic perspective; Professor X's perspective, on the other hand, strikes us as empathic and moralistic, and always has a view to the common good. You see here the difference between extraverted thinking Te (Magneto) and extraverted feeling Fe (Professor X). Keirsey would classify Professor X, an NF (Intuitive Feeler) as an 'Idealist', Magneto, a NT (Intuitive Thinker) as a 'Rational'.



But wait, Thinking types - who have either Te or Ti as a judging function - get emotional, don't they? Obviously so: they can become just as emotional as Fe or Fi types. The difference lies in how they evaluate their experiences. The first question the Thinker type asks himself is, 'What are the rules on this? How does this thing work?'. Whereas the Feeler is more interested in the question of how such-and-such affects the group atmosphere or dynamic (Fe) or one's deeply personal and natural reactions (Fi), which can be ones of empathy or antipathy. It's how you sum up life - how you evaluate it - that counts.

This goes some way to explaining why some very intelligent characters such as Professor X - who invented the Danger Room and Cerebro, among other technological marvels - should be considered as Feelers, not Thinkers; and why some very ditzy characters such as Lois Lane or Janet Van Dyne are calculating Thinkers (after all, Lois Lane is (in the old comic books at least) always plotting how to get Superman to marry her; the Wasp does the same with Hank Pym).

III. Perceiver or Judger?




Taylor gives a good description of the differences between Perceiver and Judger below:

Judging or Perceiving (J/P)- Judging or Perceiving determines your lifestyle. While Judgers are more strict in their routines and prefer to have things finished, Perceivers are more likely to be okay with leaving things up in their air. Judgers go by a set of externalized rules that keep everything in place, while Perceivers live by internalized principles that guide them and only them. Like dogs and cats.

As Chad Crandall puts it, Judgers appear as 'mappers', Perceivers as 'explorers'.

Here's where it gets difficult. Spiderman, as an INTP, would, in socionics, be called an INTj - the small 'j' comes about because his dominant function (Ti) is a judging function. But, in MBTI, he's an INTP: the uppercase 'P' at the end signifies that his extraverted function is the perceiving one. And Spiderman (in comparison to the Punisher, for example, who is an ISTJ) seems more of a Perceiver than a Judger. So what gives?

I think that the point MBTI is trying to make is that the extraverted primary or secondary function determines how we appear to others: the extraverted function is the one the world sees, and the one that makes one (in the eyes of the world) a Judger or Perceiver. Barry Allen (the Flash in the old Silver Age DC comics) works as a police scientist and leads a structured and ordered life which we'd expect of a Judger. As an ISJF, his judging function - feeling - is extraverted and so it's the one that the rest of the world sees. And indeed, his rather snippy fiancé, Iris West, calls him a 'tortoise'.



It's not entirely true to say that Judgers (in MBTI) want to impose their values on the world while Perceivers don't - all the types, to a certain extent, seek to impose their values - but a great deal of truth exists in that assertion. Take the difference between Doctor Doom (a Judger) and Mr Fantastic (a Perceiver). Doom leads an orderly, structured life and works towards goals, and both activities involve other people: he wants to: conquer the world, rescue his mother from her imprisonment in Mephisto's hellish realm, destroy the Fantastic Four... This is what the world sees of Doom. Whereas, in the case of Reed Richards, we see a man who engages in scientific research for its own sake. He doesn't want to bring the world to heel. What's more, his extraverted function (the one the world sees), which is Ne, doesn't lend itself to world-conquering.

A Judger such as Doom wants the world to follow his rules (or at least expects, like Barry Allen, the world to follow a certain structure and is disappointed if it doesn't).

Judgers seem to be more rooted than perceivers. In the Fantastic Four, the two Judger characters in the foursome, the Thing and Invisible Woman serve to keep the team grounded - a necessity when the other half of the team (Human Torch and Richards) are Perceivers and somewhat flighty.

In the Claremont-era X-Men, we find plenty of Judgers - Professor X, Jean Grey, Storm, Rogue (surprisingly enough), Cyclops - who contrast against the 'wild card' Perceivers Wolverine, Kitty Pryde, Nightcrawler and the Beast. Likewise, in the seventies-era Defenders, the Judgers (Doctor Strange, Nighthawk) serve as a counterweight to the comparatively more erratic and unstable Valkyrie, Hellcat and the Hulk. In the eighties-era New Teen Titans, we find a lot of Judgers - Robin / Nightwing, Starfire, Wonder Girl / Troia, Raven, Cyborg, Kid Flash - and only two Perceivers (Jericho, Changeling). The last two were added so as to balance out the team. A good writer of superhero team comic books will deploy various MBTI types to give balance.



IV. Introvert or Extravert?




 Introversion or extraversion in a superhero can be measured by the extent to which he wants to be seen by other people and known by other people.

A superhero or supervillain base can give us a good idea of his extraversion or introversion. Introverted heroes or villains isolate themselves in their base or hideout from others. Doctor Doom (who lives in a remote castle), Batman (who lives in a cave), Doctor Strange (who lives in a spooky mansion in Greenwich Village), Mr Fantastic (who shuts himself away in a laboratory in the Baxter Building for days at a time), Wolverine (who takes off to the Canadian Rockies now and then to be by himself) give us examples of this. In contrast, Superman lives in a 'Fortress of Solitude', which sounds rather like an introvert's den, but a gigantic, highly visible metal door can be found at the entrance, and a few metres away we see a gigantic golden key pointing to that door. It's as though Superman wants to call attention to himself; the Fortress doesn't seem as concealed as Batman's Batcave. What's more, the interiors of the Fortress are brightly lit, and in a few rooms, we find prominent statues of Superman himself as well as his friends and family. Similarly, Darkseid's base - the planet Apokolips - is festooned with images and statues of its dread ruler. Let's not forget that Darkseid, in the Legion of Superheroes series, sculpted the planet Daxam to look like his head.

Extraverts such as Superman, Wonder Woman, Captain America, Robin, Luke Cage, Dazzler, Jack Kirby's Guardian, Green Arrow, Thor, Jean Grey / Phoenix wear brightly-coloured and eye-catching uniforms; introverts prefer to dark or muted outfits (think of Batman, the Punisher, Judge Dredd, Wolverine, Cyclops, Mr Fantastic, Doctor Strange, the Phantom Stranger, Raven, Professor X...). I'll note here that ISTJs such as Dredd, Punisher, Jack Kirby's Orion, Cyclops, the Spectre, Darth Vader like to conceal themselves behind helmets, hoods and visors.

One might point out that introverts such as Spiderman or Mister Miracle wear brightly-coloured, leery costumes: true enough. But what we find here is another instance of intended ironic contrast. The introverted and shy Peter Parker designed the gaudy Spiderman costume for the purpose of working in show business; likewise, the loner and introvert Scott Free inherited a uniform from his mentor Thaddeus Brown who was a professional theatrical performer.

Batgirl / Barbara Gordon and Nightwing / Dick Grayson patterned their uniforms after Batman's, whose colours certainly doesn't match Gordon or Grayson's extraverted personalities. But Gordon added some yellow to the design, and Grayson some yellow and years later, some red.

Generally, we can pick an introvert from an extravert by asking ourselves this question: does he want to be seen and acknowledged by others, or does he prefer to conceal himself and even live in darkness? Daredevil, in his civilian identity as Matt Murdock, wears shades, dark suits and attempts to make himself look as unobtrusive as possible. Much of his superheroing seems to be done in darkness, and on rooftops, and in that regard he resembles introvert heroes such as Batman and Spiderman. Nightcrawler has the power of becoming invisible in the dark. Cyborg of the New Teen Titans attempts to cover up his body by wearing caps and trench coats - he hates people staring at him. In contrast, his teammate Changeling / Beast Boy wants to be seen as much as possible; so does Superman, who patrols, in full view, in the skies above Metropolis. Iron Man / Tony Stark clearly likes being around other people, while the Silver Surfer, who floats above Earth on his surfboard, doesn't.

V. Putting it all together: the Scarecrow

It always helps, when typing a character, to read their first appearance and origin story. Below we find the a page of World's Finest Comics #3, which introduces the Batman villain Jonathan Crane, the Scarecrow. What can we learn from it?



Let's look at where Jonathan Crane fits in to the MBTI dichotomies:

THINKER OR FEELER?

It would seem obvious that the academic Crane, a teacher of psychology, would be a Thinker - but not so fast. Professor X is, after all, a professor, but I type him as a Feeler, not a Thinker. Crane is a Thinker, but this is revealed by his behaviour more than anything else, specifically by his calculating and reasoning. In the opening panels, he delivers a reasoned discourse - and a discourse on (not coincidentally) how to manipulate people. Thinker characters who are bad guys tend to be manipulative... Then, in the last panels of the page, we find him engaged in ratiocinations again: he's performing another set of calculations. Were he a Feeler, he'd be reacting in a different way to the scorn of his colleagues: 'Nobody likes me, my life is terrible! What shall I do...'. His colleagues - and the world at large - doesn't respect him, but instead of reacting, he acts; he becomes determined to get even. He thinks in terms of problems and solutions.

INTROVERT OR EXTRAVERT?

The question answers itself. Crane resembles other brooding, isolated loner characters the Punisher, Wolverine, Peter Parker, and Bruce Wayne himself. He lives in a gloomy pad. A mousey-looking man, he doesn't want to draw attention to himself, neglects his appearance and wears shabby clothes (later on we'll see that the colours of his costume are dark and muted).

Let's go on to the next page...



JUDGER OR PERCEIVER?

Does Crane lead an orderly, structured life? Or does he take life as it comes? We see that Crane - like the other Judger characters who appear in that issue (Bruce Wayne, Clark Kent and Dick Grayson) - leads the same life, day in, day out; he isn't as erratic as Peter Parker, who aspired to work in academia for a while and made a poor teacher and student. Crane begins the story in the classroom, goes back to his pad, broods, comes back to class the next day, returns home and broods some more ('In his home, Crane's distorted brain begins thinking along fantastic lines - criminal lines'). This is a man who is accustomed to regularity and an even rhythm in his life.

Does he seek to impose his values on others? Yes indeed. Perceivers such as Reed Richards, Peter Parker, Wolverine, Oliver Queen (the bearded one in the comics, not the TV one) hold strongly-felt values but really don't care if the world is congruent with those values or not; they won't strive particularly hard to change anything. Scarecrow, on the other hand, does want to bring the world in line with his values: specifically, he wants to induce fear in others - and, at the same time, make money and gain prestige from doing so.

INTUITIVE OR SENSOR?

Do Crane's abilities and / or powers use brains or brawn? Obviously, the Scarecrow relies on his brains, and his power - altering the emotions of others (using special chemicals) - makes him an Intuitive character, not a Sensor.

In Socionics, intuitive intuition Ni is understood to be the perception of time and also cause and effect. Crane's broodings and ratiocinations are all about discovering the principles behind human psychology and how a certain cause (making people afraid) brings about a certain effect (making him wealthy and powerful).

SUMMING SCARECROW UP: INTJ

Crane is an Introvert, an Intuitive, a Thinker and a Judger. Taking into account Crane's displays of introverted intuition (planning, study of cause and effect) and his extraverted thinking (organisation of data), we can conclude he's an INTJ (INTp in Socionics). And that's how Taylor types him. It's no accident that his origin story and his character resembles other INTJ characters Doctor Doom and Batman himself - doesn't Crane's Eureka moment ('So I look like a scarecrow - that will be my symbol - a symbol of poverty and fear combined! The perfect symbol - the Scarecrow!') remind you of Bruce Wayne's?



Mark Hootsen signing off.

Tuesday, 21 July 2015

Hal Jordan / Green Lantern: ESTJ




Hal Jordan / Green Lantern II debuted in 1959. The first Green Lantern (Alan Scott) had been around since 1940 and had suffered the same fate as many Golden Age characters after WWII (such as Captain America): lack of interest from a younger generation of comic book readers. So DC decided to relaunch the Green Lantern character for a post-war audience just as they did for the Flash. A younger Green Lantern took the place of the original, was given a sleek new costume and a superpowered weapon which was scientific in origin (as opposed to magical).



The new Green Lantern was suited to the times - and to the tastes of boy comic book readers. He worked as a test pilot, and was a sober, conscientious and hard-working man - and perhaps a little bland. The Green Lantern series up until the 1970s really shines because of the artwork by the consistently great Gil Kane, but will strike today's comic book audience as being somewhat dull. I find most of the DC books of the Silver Age dull - especially Justice League of America, which I can't stand reading. As to why, I suspect that it's because most of the DC characters strike as SJs or TJs (in Keirsey's language, Guardians or Rationals). We look at the Justice League line-up and find Superman (ESFJ), Batman (INTJ), Wonder Woman (ENFJ), Green Lantern (ESTJ), the Flash (ISFJ)... A few Artisans (SPs) and Idealists (NFs) would have livened things up a bit. As it stands, the Green Lantern series, like the Justice League-, serves as a premier example of Guardian fiction.



As students of comic book history know, the Green Lantern series changed dramatically after Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams took the series over. Green Lantern teamed up with an Artisan character (Green Arrow), Neal Adams broke ground with his spectacular artwork and Denny O'Neil wrote stories on topical themes - the Manson Family murders, consumerism, overpopulation, environmentalism, feminism, native American rights, slums and most notoriously, drugs. The Green Lantern series featured the first, and perhaps the last, death by heroin overdose in a mainstream comic book.

Despite all the changes the series has gone through, Hal Jordan remains the same type - an ESTJ. Originally, when I picked up my Showcase Presents collection (which goes until the late 1970s), I found him difficult to type him straight away. I speculated that he was either an TJ or SJ, possibly an ESFJ or an ISTJ or ESTJ - I couldn't be sure. But I came to the conclusion that he wasn't an ISTJ for a number of reasons. The first of these was that a number of ISTJs appear in the Green Lantern series (especially in the O'Neil era) who are clear contrasts with Hal Jordan - that is, they are usually the bad guy. The second reason was that ISTJs in the series seem cold and unpleasant people. For all his faults, Hal Jordan comes across as a warm, pleasant, open, friendly and generous man. Related to this is the fact that the difference between the ESTJ and ISTJ lies in introversion and extraversion. When assessing the type of a character, you have to ask yourself: does he exude energy or does he draw it in? The ISTJ and ESTJ share extraverted thinking and introverted sensing. In the case of the ISTJ, the introverted sensing makes up the primary function and energy from the environment and the people around him flows into the type. The ISTJ may act upon the world using extraverted thinking, but the extraverted thinking function acts as a conduit - into his primary function, introverted sensing. Look at Judge Dredd, Darth Vader and Batman - do they exude energy or do they draw it in? The question answers itself. And, if we're to look at Hal Jordan, we see fairly quickly that his primary function - whatever it is - is an extraverted and not an introverted one.

If Hal Jordan doesn't display introverted characteristics, and if he uses extraverted thinking (like the ISTJ) to act upon the world, then he must be an ESTJ.



The ESTJ sees himself as being part of an organisation, a hierarchy, which he respects. I call the ESTJ type the Captain or the Lieutenant - in an organisation, he usually occupies the rank of a mid-level officer. He stands as the man in the middle, and finds it just as easy to receive orders as to give them. His motto may as well be, 'Learn to command by obeying'. That fits Hal Jordan to a tee. The ESTJ may break away from the organisation he belongs to - e.g., Big Barda (Mister Miracle), Two-Face (Batman) and even Captain America at times. But all that means is that the ESTJ will formulate his own idiosyncratic set of rules which he'll rigidly adhere to. (On that note, we see an unusual career trajectory for Hal. He starts the series as a test pilot, then becomes an insurance claims adjustor, then a toy salesman, and by the end of the 1970s, a bum sleeping in his car (!). By the eighties, he returns his old job as a test pilot. The point is that he remains Hal Jordan - an ESTJ, a Green Lantern in good standing, and something of a stick in the mud and authoritarian - throughout these bewildering career changes).



Introverted sensing, when it fills the secondary function in an EJ type, gives the type a conservative philosophy and worldview. The introverted sensor retains and accumulates past sensory impressions and tends to compare them favourably to the present; he will interpret the principles and first causes of the universe through the prism of these sensations, as it were. This entails conservatism (which can, but doesn't necessarily, translate into political conservatism). Again, we see that this another close fit for Hal Jordan.

On top of this, the ESTJ type will tend to jump into the fray and may seem quite impulsive. At his best, he shows admirable courage. But a fine line exists between courage and stupidity. Often when Green Lantern's power ring conks out, he'll take on the bad men without it. Like Captain America, he'll dive past a hail of bullets and wade into a pile of bad guys with his fists. Hal Jordan's impulsiveness and courage owes itself to the fact that the primary function of the EJ fills the action role (decisions, organisations, planning).

In the Socionics model, we see eight functions at work as opposed to four in Myers-Briggs. In the fourth slot in the ESTJ (LSE or ESTj in Socionics), we find Ni - introverted intuition. This makes up the 'point of least resistance' or most 'vulnerable' function in the ESTj. Ni here represents the complete opposite of the ESTj type and is eschewed, even abhorred. 

At Sociotype.Com, we find this description of Ni in the ESTj:

LSEs are usually concerned with the situation immediately in front of them, and with their personal experiences. They usually focus their productive efforts towards matters that they can personally see, hear, feel, or experience, rather than on pursuing speculative or theoretical ideas. Many LSEs concern themselves only with what they can experience or control, and do not always attempt to expend undue energy to understand what is extraneous to their experience. Being grounded in the concreteness of reality, most LSEs are not deeply aware of fantasy, mysticism, symbolism, or any otherworldly esoterics. For this reason, they may be perceived as dry and unimaginative.

LSEs may be minimally adaptive to previously unforeseen consequences. They may attempt to plan and organize their schedules in advance in order to avoid any uncertainty, and they may avoid digressing from these schedules even when they are impractical. Ever proactive, they may commit themselves to too many obligations and responsibilities...

LSEs internal mental worlds are often neglected. They are generally disinclined towards personal and existential reflection. They are focused on what is in front of them and might regard extensive philosophizing as confusing and secondary to their experience. They tend to be perpetually in motion, and may feel restless, dejected, and unproductive if forced to suspend their activities.

Now, go and read through all five volumes of Showcase Presents: Green Lantern and you'll see that the above nails Hal Jordan.

Most of the Green Lantern stories up until 1970 were written by John Broome, who inserts 'fun scientific facts' in just about every story (usually in a footnote at the bottom of the panel). This gives the book a Scientific American flavour and shows, to my mind, a lot of Te (extraverted thinking). Jung characterises the thought of the extraverted thinking as a mass of undifferentiated, usually 'scientific' facts - a jumble of empirical (about the outside world) data not organised by any central principle, i.e., any distinct theme or idea. That sums up Broome. The Green Lantern series could be seen, not only as an example of 'Guardian' fiction, but as extraverted thinking fiction.

But hey, I'm not disparaging ESTJs here: my message to them is - we need you. And we need Hal Jordan.

Mark Hootsen, signing off.








Saturday, 6 June 2015

MBTI and Jack Kirby's Fourth World: the Fast Track, Part I - EJs and IPs





I. Jack Kirby and the Fourth World

After leaving Marvel in 1970, Jack Kirby headed over to DC and threw himself into a feverish whirlwind of activity. A number of the titles he worked on - Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen, Mister Miracle, The New Gods and The Forever People - later became known as the 'Fourth World'. Kirby conceived of - and wrote and drew - a space-opera, a Wagnerian / sci-fi comic book epic. He introduced characters and concepts - such as Darkseid, the Source, Mark Moonrider - which later influenced George Lucas (Darth Vader, the Force, Luke Skywalker).




Unfortunately for Kirby - and his fans - most of the books were cancelled early in his tenure at DC, and Kirby returned to Marvel. The New Gods characters were revived in a new series in the late 1970s, and have showed up in DC comic books - and movies, TV shows and cartoons - ever since.

DC has reprinted the Fourth World series a number of times, most recently under the title Jack Kirby's Fourth World Omnibus. This four-volume set contains the revival of the New Gods in the 1980s under the title of Super Powers, a limited series which mimicked the Super Friends cartoon and comic book and which undid some of the 1970s continuity. We also find in here Kirby's Hunger Dogs (1985), a graphic novel which attempts to draw the saga to a close.

Most Kirby fans agree that his artistic skills peaked in the 1970s and atrophied somewhat (probably as a result of age and infirmity) by the 1980s. I myself like Super Powers and Hunger Dogs, but I'm forced to admit that Kirby's work there, especially the story-telling, lacked the fluidity and dynamism of old.

For this essay, I read through the four volumes and attempted to type each of the major characters (well, at least all the ones in the Who's Who of the DC Universe entry, see below) according to Myers-Briggs.




This wasn't that difficult, given that Taylor's blog Zombies Ruin Everything has typed just about every major Marvel and DC character (many of them co-created by Kirby). Reading through Taylor's personality profiles gave me the overall gist of each personality type - as it appears in popular culture - and so I could match each of Kirby's Fourth World characters to each 'stock type'.

I did run into a few obstacles. One of them was that many characters don't enjoy that much screen time, so to speak; we see them for a few pages and then they're gone. We only see Izaya's wife Avia for a few pages; likewise, Darkseid's ex-wife Tigra. How are we to type them? The answer is, by going off things such as visual cues. It's a point of contention in Myers-Briggs as to whether or not a person will 'look' their type; but in comic books, characters certainly look theirs.

Kirby invented a lot of characters, and a few superhero teams and ensembles and like most creators, he made it a practice not to include more than one of each Myers-Briggs type. Look at the Fantastic Four: Mister Fantastic, INTP; Invisible Woman, ENFJ; Human Torch, ESFP; the Thing, ESFJ. We'll find, as a general rule throughout comics, that types don't double up, so to speak, in superhero teams - one major exception being the current Guardians of the Galaxy. This means, then, that once we type five characters in a six man team, we can infer - by guesswork and a process of elimination - what the type of the six will be.

So without further ado, let's begin. I'll follow the practice of Calise Sellers and divide up the types into IPs (Introverted Perceivers), EPs (Extraverted Perceivers), IJs (Introverted Judgers) and EJs (Extraverted Judgers). For part I of this article, I'll focus on the EJs and IPs.

II. The EJs in the Fourth World

Let's start with the EJs - the Men of Action. To understand the EJ type a little better, we need to recap some of my earlier post.

It helps to think of the four functions in Myers-Briggs as belonging to a particular sphere. Each of the spheres gets wider and wider as it includes more things.

The most immediate sphere concerns yourself - what you see when you look in yourself at your own thoughts and feelings. One always undertakes introspection in that sphere: introverted thinking or feeling. The introverted thinker or feeler shuts out the external field and concentrates either on getting his thoughts in order or sorting through and evaluating his subjective (emotional) experiences. The EJ type tends to dislike this sort of activity; introspection - or what Calise Sellers calls Details and Data - makes up their repressed, inferior fourth function.

The next sphere represents a step outside one's head and into the real world, so to speak: the world of your actual friends, family, colleagues, business associates, neighbours. Here you look outward (and use the perceiving functions - sensing and intuiting) and develop a philosophy of life - what is or could be. Extraverted sensors appreciate visuals and the finer things in life, including the arts and fashion, but on the negative, can develop a philosophy of extraordinary cynicism, even pessimism (see the Rust Cohle character in the TV series True Detective). Extraverted intuitives enjoy exploring possibilities and visualising what could take the place of what is - they like dreams, ideals, fantasies and inventions; but they can often be too impractical, disorganised, spontaneous, and as a result, never get the chance to put their intuitions into a meaningful context (this is especially true of the ENFP and ENTP types). Or perhaps they babble on endlessly about all the connections and patterns they see out there in reality - think of Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes, an INTP, in the TV show Sherlock.

Both of these descriptions apply to the types who have extraverted sensing or intuiting as a primary or secondary function; they don't apply to the EJ, who has it as a tertiary function.

The EJ doesn't eschew extraverted intuition or sensing entirely: the ENFJ type (who may be a cult leader, see below) may enjoy finery; an ESTJ type, such as Captain America, may hold to ideals of freedom, patriotism, honour. Generally, though, the EJ doesn't make this sphere - the immediate personal, or what Sellers calls Observations and Motivations - a top priority; he doesn't care much about actual, real life human beings and what their hopes, visions, aspirations, foibles and quirks are. (Ask the typical EJ, 'Want to know how the world really works?' and he'll answer, 'No'). It's for this reason that the EJ, especially in a leadership role, can strike others as being ruthless.

The second sphere concerns an organisation - a corporation, a political group, a superhero team, an army, even a state. Action, planning, decisions and judgements count here the most. It's here that the EJ really shines: he jumps into action (and may appear to be impulsive) and makes the sphere of decisions and planning (or Action, as Sellers calls it) his top priority and he uses his primary function in that field. He will perform one of two roles: Master of Men (extraverted thinking), which means he's an executive or army officer type, or Communitarian (extraverted feeling), which means he's geared to what his particular organisation (whether it be a corporation, church group, political group, city, nation, planet) values and loves.

Finally we arrive at the broadest sphere of all - understanding the root principles and causes of all things, what may be called metaphysics. The EJ type uses his secondary function here. The primary and secondary functions appear to complement one another. A great statesman or military leader, whose default action role is that of an executive, may experience intuitions - introverted intuitions. He may know, in a psychic flash, what his enemy's next move will be; or he may trust in the fates and know - without being able to say why - that his audacious military gamble will succeed. Generally, this type believes in God, or Fate, or something larger than himself - something mystical that he can tap into at will. This holds true for the ENTJ and ENFJ type.

The other EJ types, the ESTJs and ESFJs, understand the universe and metaphysics through the body. They measure, using their bodies, weight, mass and volume and believe that things can be moved around with the application of the right amount of physical force. Being introverted sensors, too, they cling to accumulated sense impressions - impressions of the past. Jung, in his Psychological Types (1921) sounds quite mystical here. He posits that the sense impressions of one generation passes onto the next; accumulated sense impressions sit in the collective unconscious common all to human beings.

So let's look through the four EJ types. We'll start with the easiest of them all:

ENTJ: Executive / General; Shadow self: Tyrant.

Stock examples: Magneto (X-Men); Loki (Thor); Lex Luthor (Superman); Kingpin (Daredevil); Megatron (Transformers).

This type goes into Action first and plays the role of Master of Men, using extraverted thinking, Te; he also uses introverted intuition (Ni) to divine the Principles of the universe - the Principles being God / Fate.

Unquestionably, Darkseid belongs here. Perhaps he could be considered the poster boy for the ENTJ type.




Many other ENTJs appear in Kirby's Fourth World. Among them we can find Heggra, Darkseid's mother (a rival ENTJ who he poisons for the throne)... 




And then we have Mantis the 'energy vampire', who has ambitions to rule Earth with the race of 'bug' people who live underground in New Genesis.



ESTJ: Mid-Ranking Officer / the Second in Command; shadow self: Draconian Drill-Sergeant.

STOCK EXAMPLES: Princess Leia (Star Wars); Captain America; Two-Face (Batman); Wonder Girl (New Teen Titans (1980s era)).

Like the ENTJ, the ESTJ goes into action with extraverted thinking Te, and is a Master of Men; unlike the ENTJ, the ESTJ uses introverted sensing - that is, one's bodily sensations and impressions - to deduce the Principles of the universe, which, by his reckoning, are Weight, Mass and Volume.

What this means is that the ESTJ will more often than not be an executive and a leader of some type, and because of the introverted sensing, will be focused either on physical fitness or on asceticism - pitting one's body (which contains one's subjective sense of self) against the world. The type also, because of the introverted sensing, are more likely to be biased towards the past (conservativism). They feel a sense of loyalty to their family and the organisation they belong to.

As a character, the ESTJ type is more likely to occupy the rank of Lieutenant or Captain than General. That is, they perform the role of second-in-command rather than first.

Big Barda, as leader of the Female Furies Battalion and member of the elite Special Powers Force, fits the role of the ESTJ type perfectly. In the comic book world, you are your job - and Barda's job is to be a drill sergeant.



ESFJ: The Mother Hen; shadow self: the Smotherer.

STOCK EXAMPLES: Superman; The Thing (Fantastic Four); Starfire (New Teen Titans); Cersei Lannister (Game of Thrones); Dr Leonard 'Bones' McCoy (Star Trek).

The ESFJ uses extraverted feeling, Fe, and is a Communitarian in his default action role; like the ESTJ, the ESFJ is an introverted sensor and understands the Principles of the universe as being Weight, Mass and Volume.

Orion's girlfriend (and Himon's daughter) Bekka, who first appears in Hunger Dogs, gives us a good example of the ESFJ type. Caring and maternal, the ESFJ in popular culture is usually a woman, or at least, very motherly.




I type Big Bear as an ESFJ because, out of all his team members, he seems to be the most Communitarian - the welfare of his fellow members (and civilian bystanders around him) counts the most to him. In addition, he resembles the Thing - another Kirby ESFJ character.



Granny Goodness stands out as one of the few bad guy ESFJs in comic books. She represents an ESFJ gone wrong. In a perverse way, she's a Communitarian, and what's more, her Orphanage is, it could be argued, an extension of her introverted sensing, Si. The Orphanage indoctrinates young men - and women - in Darkseid values and the values of Apokolips, and is conservative, even nostalgic. It places a great emphasis on physical culture - that is, physical training, not to mention disciplinary beatings - which again ties in with Si, but a bad Si.



ENFJ: Nurturing Leader / Hero Teacher; shadow self: Manipulative Guru / Cult Leader.

STOCK EXAMPLES: Dick Grayson / Nightwing (New Teen Titans); Wonder Woman;

Jean Grey (X-Men); Invisible Woman (Fantastic Four); Optimus Prime (Transformers); Obi-Wan Kenobi (Star Wars); Robin Williams in Dead Poets Society (1989); Hank Scorpio in The Simpsons.

Like the ESFJ, the ENFJ is a Communitarian; like the ENTJ, he understands the universe as God / Fate as perceived by introverted intuition, Ni.

Usually in popular culture this character will be a guru, evangelist, teacher or nurturing leader and thrives on being part of the group and before an audience. The ENFJ possesses a certain theatricality. But one can't confuse the ENFJ with the 'performer' type, the ESFP. The ENFJ, unlike the ESFP, doesn't work as a lone wolf; he seeks to weld a group together. His favourite word is synergy.

Mark Moonrider of the Forever People is described as a 'natural leader', and so he is. A natural leader like the ESTJ (Big Barda) or the ENTJ (Darkseid), you say? Not quite: he's too nice to be either one of those. It's for that reason that I put him in the ENFJ category. I'll admit that I cheated a little on this one: Mark Moonrider reminds me a little of Dick Grayson / Nightwing, another 'natural leader' and ENFJ who has led three or four super-teams.



The poster-boy for the 'ENFJ gone wrong' will always be, of course, Glorious Godfrey. A denizen of Apokolips, he travels to Earth and pretends to be an evangelist. He intoxicates his audiences with his mesmerising rhetoric and forms a militia called the Justifiers, who beat up people, destroy books and artefacts, and practice suicide bombing in the name of religion. What is the religion, you might ask? 'Anti-Life', which boils down to letting Darkseid doing your thinking for you and hailing Darkseid as a messiah.


III. The IPs in the Fourth World

It should be noted here that the IPs reverse-mirror the EJs. While the EJ disdains introspection (Details and Data) and doesn't have much time for human beings in the real world (Observations and Motivations), the IPs make Details and Observations their primary and secondary functions respectively. We see that their tertiary function is used in the sphere of the organisation and the unit (Action), which means that, while they can undertake decisions and planning, and do a good job, they don't accord them a high priority - for that reason, they can appear to others as lazy and not being highly motivated. In addition, they rarely seek out leadership roles. Reed Richards / Mister Fantastic stands as one of the few examples of the IP as leader of a superhero group; this exception proves the rule.

When the IP type does go into action, he takes up a default action role - either Zen Warrior or Master of the Body. The Zen Warrior uses introverted intuition. As a swordsman, he knows, by a gut feeling or hunch, when and where exactly to deliver the killing blow with his sword; as a pilot, he knows how to keep his spacecraft from colliding with that enemy spacecraft or asteroid. The Master of the Body, on the other hand, is just that: someone who practises physical self-discipline and knows how to use his body to defeat his foes (see Mister Fantastic, or a certain famous escape artist below).


ISTP: Taciturn Loner; shadow self: Cold Fish.

STOCK EXAMPLES: Wolverine (X-Men); Han Solo (Star Wars); Elektra (Daredevil); Black Widow (Avengers); Daredevil / Matt Murdock; James Bond; Deathstroke the Terminator (New Teen Titans); Darth Maul (Star Wars).

The ISTP sees himself as a Technician / Scientist (introverted thinking applied to Details and Data). In his philosophy of life, he is a Realist / Aesthetician (extraverted sensing applied to Observations and Motivations).

A staple in the movies and the comic books, the ISTP often appears as a 'lone wolf' mercenary, assassin or spy who makes up his own rules. The ISTP comic character will be graceful and fluid in their movements - efficiency in motion - and skilled at using a weapon, which almost appears as an extension of their body. Like his brother type, the ESTP, he dresses well.

Only two ISTPs appear in the Fourth World saga: Lashina of the Female Furies and Devilance the Pursuer. The former is a cold, quiet member of the Furies who uses whips and belts with great skill, the latter, a hunter for Darkseid who uses a lance.






Again, I cheated on this one. Lashina looks and behaves a lot like the Black Widow and Elektra, while Devilance reminds me of Darth Maul.

INFP: The Flower Child; shadow self: the Waif

STOCK EXAMPLES: Luke Skywalker (Star Wars); Nightcrawler (X-Men); Scarlet Witch (Avengers); David Duchovny in X-Files.

The INFP defines himself as a Poet / Romantic (introverted feeling, Details and Data) and holds to an Idealist / Inventor philosophy of life (extraverted intuition, Observations and Motivations).

The INFP could be best described as someone who consciously isolates himself from his surroundings and the people around him, who prefers to dwell in their subjectivity (that is, their thoughts and feelings). At the same time he is continually looking for and wanting to explore possibilities beyond the present. In other words, he's Luke Skywalker on Tatooine - someone who pays little attention to the present and invests almost nothing in it while keeping their eye on bright horizons. Typically, in popular culture, he just doesn't fit in; he will be an individualist who rejects the family or community or organisation he is born into and seeks something more. While the ESTJ can seem a natural fit for an organisation, the INFP can appear to be a natural un-fit.

Beautiful Dreamer's name evokes the INFP type the best, and Beautiful Dreamer should be classified as an INFP, being a gentle soul who can project illusions, images (some beautiful, others ugly and horrifying) of things that aren't there - her powers draw upon extraverted intuition, Ne.



(Again, I've cheated here: Beautiful Dreamer reminds me a lot of another Kirby creation, Scarlet Witch, an INFP).

Another candidate for INFP status is Forager. He lives in a colony of insect-like humanoids on New Genesis but rejects their ways. He dreams of reconciliation with the 'eternals' of New Genesis and freedom. His mentor, Prime-One - an Obi-Wan-type figure - is killed by the All-Widow, the queen of the colony, as part of a ritual, much to Forager's chagrin, and he escapes to Earth to warn Orion of a pending invasion by Darkseid's minion Mantis. Forager seems much more humanoid than his fellow 'bugs', and certainly he's very different - much more sensitive and questioning. We see parallels between him and Luke Skywalker.



Finally we come to the most prominent of all the INFPs in the Fourth World: Mister Miracle. We see a lot of similarity between him and Forager. The son of Izaya the Highfather, ruler of New Genesis, Scott Free is adopted by Darkseid as part of a peace treaty between Apokolips and New Genesis (INFP characters usually are adopted - Nightcrawler, Luke Skywalker, Scarlet Witch, Fox Mulder - or at least don't know who their real parents are) and grows up in Granny Goodness' Orphanage, which of course he loathes. Both Metron and Himon of New Genesis act as his mentors, and he learns - in secret - to build some technological wonder-devices, including a Mother Box. When attempting to escape, he is confronted by Darkseid and Himon. This scene evokes the ending of Empire Strikes Back (1980), in which Luke's father, Darth Vader, asks Luke to join him:



Scott, like Luke, doesn't go over to the dark side of the force.




He then jumps, like Luke, into a cylindrical chute.



INTP: Super-Scientist; shadow self: Egghead / Aspbergers-ish Super-Geek

STOCK EXAMPLES: Mister Fantastic (Fantastic Four), Doctor Manhattan (Watchmen), Man-Bat (Batman), Peter Parker / Spiderman, Victor Frankenstein, Sherlock Holmes, Sheldon from Big Bang Theory, Mr Freeze (Batman), the Lizard (Spiderman).

The INTP defines himself as a Technician / Super-Scientist, and his philosophy of life is Idealist / Inventor. In other words, he uses introverted thinking for Details / Data and extraverted intuition for Observations / Motivations.

We find a lot of INTPs in the comic books, and especially in Kirby's career - think of all the 'monster'-themed titles he worked on for Marvel and DC in the 1950s and early 1960s. 'Super-scientists' and 'Mad scientists who invent a creature which destroys the world' abound in these.

In the first issue of New Gods, Metron declares 'Who runs the universe matters not! What makes it run is my prime objective!'. He demonstrates some of the more amoral aspects of the INTP. Not interested in politics - only science - he gives away the secrets of Boom Tube teleportation to Darkseid in exchange for something called the 'X-Element' - an element he needs for the engine of his Moebius Chair (which is a vehicle which can traverse time and space). It could be argued that Metron is committing treason here. After the outbreak of war between Apokolips and New Genesis, he goes over to the good guys, but generally he doesn't participate in the action much.




Vykin the Black of the Forever People appears to be another INTP hero and a super-scientist type, who is always lugging around the Mother Box as though it's some piece of scientific equipment, e.g., a Geiger counter.



Two bad guy INTPs, Makkari and Simyan, run the Evil Factory, which is devoted to breeding creatures of destruction to wreak havoc on Earth. Makkari and Simyan resemble the Enclave in Fantastic Four - more Kirby super-scientists who have gone bad.



ISFP: Sensitive Bohemian; shadow self: Hippie Bum

STOCK EXAMPLES: Jeff Bridges in The Big Lebowski (1998); Legolas (Lord of the Rings); Jericho (New Teen Titans); Silk Spectre II (Watchmen); Poison Ivy (Batman).

The ISFP defines himself as a Poet / Romantic (Details and Data) and his philosophy of life consists of Realism / Aestheticism (Observations and Motivations).

As a character in popular culture, he more often than not doesn't pay much attention to politics and the outer world; he prefers to dwell on subjective and emotional experiences (introverted feeling). His realist philosophy of life (extraverted sensing) gives him a love of the plastic (that is, form-giving) arts, doing things with his hands and creating. While not an extraverted feeler, he can be empathic and he usually seeks peace and the putting of an end to all quarrels and conflicts. (Rest assured, however, if you start with him, he'll finish it). Usually ISFPs appear as graceful, almost elfin characters.

Lightray of New Genesis gives us the best example of the ISFP in Kirby's Fourth World. He serves as the cheerful and light counter-weight to the gloomy, brooding and destructive Orion.




He uses his powers to create beautiful things. In one instance, he remoulds an ugly creature of Apokolips into a New Genesis machine.



Another elfin character who likes creating beautiful things with his powers (or rather, his equipment - his 'cosmic cartridges') is Serifan.



Who can forget the cosmic cartridge which sends one young boy on a LSD-type trip:



Lastly, another gentle hippie type, who doesn't get much screen time, is Izaya's wife (and Mister Miracle's mother) Avia - another candidate for ISFP:



 

End of Part I. Mark Hootsen signing off.









 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



 


 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Saturday, 23 May 2015

Myers-Briggs and the Superheroes: an Introduction




I.

The Myers-Briggs system of personality typing (MBTI, or Myers-Briggs Type Indicator) can be used for lots of things, including careers counselling and self-improvement, but to me, the best use one can get out of it is typing characters in popular culture - movies, TV, comic books. Some sites do a great job in that regard, and I point to Taylor's Zombies Ruin Everything blog as a prime example (I shall be linking to Taylor's personality profiles throughout this article). Typing characters in your favourite comic books really enhances your enjoyment of the stories. In future posts, I'll be typing some characters; this post should serve as an introduction to typing - as a manual.

To go through Myers-Brigg very briefly...

Everyone perceives (and acts in) the world in four ways: sensing, intuiting, thinking and feeling. Sensing (S) refers to physical sense perception of a thing
and the drawing of meanings from it. After perceiving a thing, sensing links it up to a greater perception of the whole, in the same way we can infer what a completed jigsaw puzzle looks like from one piece. Intuition (I), on the other hand, means the perception of mental things - things which aren't out there in the material world. Intuition views concepts - overall ideas of things which we draw from seeing patterns and making connections; it could be characterised as whole pattern recognition.





 
These two - sensing and intuiting - belong in the category of perceiving functions; thinking (T) and feeling (F) make up the judging functions. Instead of merely perceiving - i.e., sensing and intuiting - the judging functions criticise, evaluate, draw conclusions and map out pathways to goals. Thinking evaluates things according to their use - i.e., it determines their usefulness - and puts things in order. But thinking only sees small portions of things. Thinking, applied to a painting, only sees the brushstrokes. Feeling, on the other hand, evaluates the overall meaning, significance and value of a thing, and sees the entire painting for what it is, not just the brushstrokes. Thinking views the world through the prism of thought, feeling through emotions.




Everyone uses the same four functions, but certainly personality types are biased towards one over the other three. We have thinking-dominant types, sensing-dominant, and so forth. This gives us four categories. But, to complicate matters further, the perceiving and judging functions look either outward or inward - that is, they are either extraverted (E) or introverted (I). So we have dominant introverted sensing (Si) types, dominant extraverted thinking (Te) types, etc., which leads to a total of eight types.

How can sensing be introverted or extraverted? Extraverted sensing means paying close attention to the world of the five senses and losing one's sense self outside in the world - being outside of one's self and one's body. In contrast, introverted sensing focuses on one's bodily sensations and one's physical self, and often a dominant introverted sensing type will be interested in physical fitness and even asceticism. In addition, the introverted sensor stockpiles his memories and impressions of the past, and is nearly always comparing them to the present and finding the present wanting; he tends towards nostalgia and conservatism. Extraverted sensors, on the other hand, live in the here and now.





Extraverted intuition is used to detect possibilities, things that aren't out there in the material world but could be. It could be called the faculty of inventors and entrepreneurs. Introverted intuition focuses inwards and tries to determine the essence of things - what is such and such a thing really, truly is - and makes predictions about the future using hunches, guesses, 'psychic' intuition and knowledge which can come in the form of a dream or vision.

Extraverted intuition expands, introverted intuition narrows. Tell an extraverted intuitor to find a pathway through a forest, and he will see multiple pathways, multiple possibilities, and be enamoured, intoxicated even, by the fact that so many possibilities are presenting themselves. The introverted intuitor will see the one pathway which is the quickest and easiest and just 'know' - without coming up with much of a logical justification - that it is the right one.



Extraverted thinking seeks to put things out there, in the material world, to use, and relies upon a criteria of usefulness to determine their value. An extraverted thinker looks at people as a military man or executive would look at them: a strong instrumentalist bias exists - that is to say, a view of people as a means to achieve a certain end. Introverted thinking, on the other hand, believes in putting one's thoughts in order: sifting through information and analysing and breaking down things into their constituent parts - the operative word here is systems analysis.






Finally, we are left with the difference between extraverted and introverted feeling. The former looks outwards - to one's friends, family, community, social milieu - and evaluates to the criteria of shared feeling, what other people feel. Introverted feeling looks to one's inner emotions, inner feelings - how one feels about it - as a criteria and seeks to shield them (and one's self) from others; it wants to do its own thing. It infers the feelings of others through analogy: that is, 'That other fellow must be like me, so, he's feeling what I'm feeling'. It can be empathic while at the same nurturing and protective of its own self.





One of the eight functions, introverted and extraverted, must dominate in a certain personality type; but one is never a 'pure' type. The dominant function operates with the help of the other three functions, which help balance the self. For example, one may be an extraverted sensor, and live in the moment, and be a somewhat crude and sensual individual; at the same time, this will be balanced out by a secondary function - for instance, introverted thinking, which will at least give that individual a low animal cunning. Likewise, an introverted intuitor, who broods a lot on the meaning and the workings of the universe and ponders visions, will be balanced out by the extraverted thinking function - which excels at organising and directing men. If the primary or dominant function is introverted, the secondary is always extraverted. And vice versa: an extraverted primary is balanced by an introverted secondary.

Given that no type has the same primary and secondary function as another type, we now have not eight but 16 types.



II.

One can familiarise with the basic Myers-Briggs and Jungian concepts - perceiving, judging, intuition, sensing, thinking, feeling, extraversion, introversion, etc. - without too much difficulty, but most people will run into problems when they try and view all this as a whole. After all, the system contains 16 (!) personality types - how are you to get to know them all? The sheer number of types presents an obstacle. After all, one has to learn only 12 notes to play music.

The answer, to me, lies subdividing the 16 types into four or so groups. Once you learn the basic traits of each group, then you can focus on an individual type within the group in more detail. That's the approach Keirsey takes: he splits the 16 types into four - the SJs ('Guardians'), SPs ('Artisans'), NJs ('Idealists') and NTs ('Rationalists').





Studying Keirsey's categories will help you get a handle on Myers-Briggs. But I think an improvement on Keirsey's system can be found in Calise Seller's work. I identify four groups there. I'll list them, and give a nice or neutral title for each type, and a nasty one which represents the Shadow (Jung's term for bad or evil alter-ego).


IPs (Ruminators / Solipsists) - introverted perceivers;
EJs (Technocrats / Tyrants) - extraverted judgers;
EPs (Theatrical Impresarios / Used Car Salesmen) - extraverted perceivers;
IJs (Lawgivers / Mad Monks) - introverted judgers.

When it comes to MBTI and comic book characters especially, we are dealing with stock types and caricatures, and simplification and exaggeration - as well as myths and misconceptions - all have a part to play there. In real life, we'll never encounter INTJs as cartoony and hyperbolised as Batman or Emperor Palpatine (from Star Wars), but the exaggerated, even distorted, depictions of the INTJ type will help us remember the INTJ designation and what it stands for. We need the exaggerations, and absolutes of black and white, when trying to work out a character's type.

The functions in each of the types - sensing, intuiting, judging, perceiving - are used, in Sellers' system, to answer four main questions:


1) Details and Data: Who am I and what's my role in life?

This line of questioning concerns one's self and how one relates to one's self - specifically, one's innermost thoughts and feelings. Do I organise my thoughts in a methodical fashion, or do I study and explore my emotional experiences? In other words, do I habitually engage in thinking (putting my thoughts to use in a logical and efficient manner) or feeling (appreciating the meaning and significance of great emotional experiences)? Am I technician and laboratory scientist by nature, or am I a poet and artist, even a mystic...

To engage in such activities - feeling or thinking - one must look inside oneself; one must practice introverted thinking or feeling (Ti or Fi).

There are only two answers to the question: 'I am a Poet / Artist' (introverted feeler) or 'I am a Scientist / Technician' (introverted thinker).


2) Motivations and Observations: What's life about and how does the world really work?

Here one develops a philosophy of life - not marine life, or micro-organic life, but human life - and holds to one of two competing theses. The first is: what's true is what is (realism, materialism); the second, what's true is what could be (idealism). The latter could involve the exploration of all sorts of exciting possibilities and perspectives in life. In either case - looking at what is or what's possible - one is looking outwards; one is either practising extraverted sensing or extraverted intuiting, respectively (Se and Ne). An extraverted sensor is a Realist / Aesthetician, an extraverted intuitor an Idealist / Inventor.


3) Actions, Consequences, Decisions, Planning: What's my default action role?

Over the course of a comic book story, a lead character will habitually play one of these four roles: Master of Men; Zen Warrior; Master of the Body; Communitarian.

The four roles require both extraverted and introverted functions. A character in Zen Warrior mode will accomplish some difficult task, cleanly and efficiently, without thinking about it and with perfect concentration and faith in the outcome; he goes into action like a 'full metal jacket', with 'perfect aim', to borrow a phrase from Kubrick's Full Metal Jacket (1987)). This calls for introverted intuition (Ni), the seeing of the one 'right' answer in one's head and arriving at in a flash, 'without thinking'. Being a Master of Men requires extraverted thinking (Te) - putting people to use in an organisation and hierarchy. To be a Communitarian, you need to appreciate, understand and respect the values of one's group - whether it be one's family, community, nation, state, planet: this needs extraverted feeling (Fe). Last but not least is Master of the Body: one must be physically fit, and practice physical self-restraint and self-discipline, to pit one's body against the world (introverted sensing, Si).


4) Worldview, Principles, Root Causes. How are we to understand the workings of the universe and how can these be manipulated to our advantage?

There are four answers to this question. The first is, the universe, or prime mover in the universe, is God / Fate; or, in Star Wars, the Force; it can be perceived, and used, through divine or cosmic insight. The second answer is that the universe is a Machine; one can pull its levers and put it to use through understanding of engineering. The third answer is that the universe is Feeling; the manipulation of others' feelings will help us get what we want. The fourth and final answer is that the universe is Weight, Mass and Volume; the measurement of it - through our bodies - will enable us to gauge the right amount of physical force to get it to move.

The four answers involve, respectively, 1) introverted intuition, Ni; 2) extraverted thinking, Te; 3) extraverted feeling, Fe; 4), introverted sensing, Si.

The word 'manipulation' does make the process sound cynical. Let's hope that the individual uses the four abilities - Ni, Te, Fe, Si - for good and not for evil.

In total, we find there are four main questions - regarding Details, Observations, Principles, Actions - and four functions per personality type. Each function can be matched up to each question. As we shall see, each of the four categories - IP, EP, IJ, EJ - answer the questions in a different order; the IP category will answer the Data and Observations questions first, for example. So we see a beautiful symmetry at work.

IP:   Data, Observations, Actions, Principles (acronym DOAP);
 
EJ:  Actions, Principles, Observations, Data (acronym APOD);
 
EP: Observations, Data, Principles, Action (acronym ODPA);
 
IJ:   Principles, Actions, Data, Observations (acronym PADO).

 

III.

To repeat, a MBTI personality type contains symmetrical opposites which offset one another. Take, for example, an intellectual egghead character such as Mister Fantastic (of the Fantastic Four) or Spiderman - both are INTP and both use introverted thinking (Ti) as a primary function. The INTP doesn't represent a 'pure' introverted thinking type, because the secondary function - extraverted intuition, Ne - offsets the introversion of introverted thinking and grounds the type in the real world. The secondary function serves as an anchor which prevents the type from drifting away. For example: Mister Fantastic uses plenty of introverted thinking, and, at the same time, his career as an inventor and space explorer (both of which rely on extraverted intuition, Ne) offsets the introversion and prevents him from becoming a purely theoretical person.





The fourth and final function - called the 'repressed' or 'inferior' function in Jung - mirrors in the reverse the primary function. In the case of the INTP type, the fourth function, it's extraverted feeling, Fe, constitutes the reverse mirror image of the primary, introverted feeling, Ti. From the Myers-Briggs literature, we know that the fourth, inferior function comes to the fore in a time of stress. Strangely enough, it becomes transmuted in the process: Fe in the INTP  and ISTP types (see Wolverine below) appears as a crazy, exaggerated Fe, a caricature of normal, healthy Fe. In Sellers' system, the inferior function is used to answer the fourth and final question in the sequence - and doesn't do a good job of it, as we shall see.






Let's go through each category and see how the process (Sellers calls it the 'cognition process') works. Each of the four questions (a 'cognition step') will be answered by one of the four functions, and we'll look at how each cognition step is embodied in the life and career of a famous personality from the movies, comic books, history and the Bible.


IP: Introverted Sensor: Han Solo from Star Wars: ISTP.


 

Han's primary function is introverted thinking, Ti. When left alone by himself, he's naturally inclined to being a technician or engineer (Details and Data = Scientist / Technician), having a brilliant analytical understanding of how the mechanics of his space craft, the Millennium Falcon, works. He adopts a realist and materialist philosophy of life, telling Luke condescendingly that 'There's no such as the Force' and that 'Hokey old time religions' (such as the Jedi religion) are a waste of time. This is Observations and Motivations, and the function here used is Han's secondary function, extraverted sensing, Se - Realist / Aesthetician. In action, he assumes the default action role of Zen Warrior (introverted intuition, Ni, as applied to Actions, Decisions, Consequences, Planning). Think of that scene in Empire Strikes Back (1980), when he walks into the dining room in Bespin and finds Darth Vader waiting for him. It's a trap! Han's assessment of the situation changes from positive to negative in the space of a split second. Without thinking, he draws his pistol and fires at Vader in one fluid motion. (As we know, he doesn't succeed - Vader deflects the laser blast with a wave of his hand).

Finally, we come to Principles, World View, Root Causes. The IP type doesn't do well here. Metaphysics, the big picture and understanding what the universe is made up of - much less how to manipulate it - are not his fortĂ©. This holds true even for Han's fellow IP, Luke Skywalker, an INFP. Luke doesn't understand Root Causes very well, either. He doesn't quite 'get' the Force. That's why mentor figures Obi-Wan and Yoda are constantly admonishing him for his ignorance throughout the series - as are would-be mentor figures Vader and Emperor Palpatine.

Han Solo: full marks for Details, Observations, Actions and a fail for Principles. But no type can be good at everything.


EJ: Extraverted Judger - Superman: ESFJ.





Superman's primary function is extraverted feeling, Fe. Superman's default action role is Communitarian, which requires Fe. Being a strongman, he understands the principle of the universe as being Weight, Mass, Volume, and uses introverted sensing, Si, to measure it and determine the precise amount of force to apply. In terms of philosophy of life, he views life as it could be, something that contains great possibilities - you could say he's a utopian, which makes him an Idealist / Inventor. His personal philosophy - Motivations and Observations - draws upon extraverted intuition, Ne.

Where does Superman fall down? None of the EJ types like introversion and being 'left alone with their thoughts' - or feelings. Superman continually asks himself 'Who am I?' and experiences a personal crisis whenever he quits being Superman and gives up superheroics. I call the ESFJ type the 'Mother Hen'. The type is often accused of smothering people and being over-protective. If an ESFJ gives up his default role - Communitarian - he has no one left to smother. What does he do?

We can the same failure to deal with introversion in another EJ type, the Jack Kirby New Gods villain Darkseid, who is an ENTJ. In a great story arc in the Justice League of America series, Darkseid is brought back to life after having been dead for some time. He delivers a monologue to his underlings while holding a beautiful flower in his hand and sniffing it; he tells them that his death and resurrection has made him more reflective, and appreciative of beauty and aesthetics. But, says Darkseid, such moments constitute weakness - weakness which he will never allow himself to experience again - and he crushes the flower in his fist.



A Myers-Briggs psychologist would say that Darkseid's repressed function here is obviously introverted feeling, Fi. Darkseid resists introversion, and he wants to expunge the introverted feeler - a Poet / Artist - from his soul.

EP: Extraverted Sensor: Socrates: ENTP.





Michael Pierce identifies the ancient Greek philosopher and historical personage Socrates as an ENTP.  Socrates believes that life is about the exploration of exciting possibilities and perspectives - extraverted intuition Ne here is applied to Observations, Motivations, making him an Idealist / Inventor. It's not for nothing that Socrates was accused of scepticism, relativism and sophism. We can say that Socrates, like many an ENTP, was in love with extraverted intuition and all it brought forth. This was balanced by an introverted side - Socrates saw himself as a thinker, philosopher and a rationalist and introspected via introverted thinking (Ti, as applied to Data and Details - Scientist / Technician).

He understood the universe as Feeling (Fe, as applied to Root Causes and Principles). There's a strong element of emotional manipulation in Socrates, and he was accused of charlatanism in his lifetime. Many prominent Athenians didn't trust him. The ENTP type in myth and popular culture is often associated with tricksters, fast talkers, hucksters, and chaos-bringers.

Where do the ENTPs and other EPs fall down typically? In the field of Actions, Decision and Planning. Despite the ENTP's penchant for cleverness and manipulation (and all EPs are good at the latter), their plans don't work out. Socrates lacked the political and organisational skills of the EJ type, as we know from history. We can see that another ENTP type - Saul Goodman in the TV show Breaking Bad - just wasn't a good organiser as Walter White, an INTJ. In DC comics' supervillain group, the Secret Society of Super Villains, the Joker doesn't strike us as being a leader type like fellow team members Lex Luthor or Darkseid, both ENTJs; in Marvel's Avengers, Iron Man / Tony Stark doesn't lead as well as Captain America, an ESTJ. The ENTP is no Master of Men.

If it's any consolation, another EP type - Lois Lane, an ESTP - doesn't do well with regards to Planning and Decisions either. Her convoluted plots to manipulate Superman into marriage always fail.



IJ: Extraverted Judger - Moses: INFJ.



The INFJ often appears in popular culture (and myth) as The Sage, and is regarded as the most spooky and mystical of the types. We find the antecedent to Sage-types (such as Gandalf in Lord of the Rings, and Izaya the High Father in New Gods) in the Biblical figure of Moses. Like Moses, Gandalf and Izaya wear dresses, have long beards and carry staves. Yoda likewise wears a dress and carries a stick.

Moses receives the Word of God on Mount Sinai. Here divine insight - or more prosaically, introverted intuition - is used to determine the makeup of the universe and Root Causes, Principles and World View. In his Actions and Decisions, Moses as a prophet and leader takes up the role of Communitarian, which draws upon extraverted feeling, Fe. By organising his thoughts and putting them into order as a lawgiver to Israel and codifying the law in four books, he uses introverted thinking Ti, and defines himself as a thinking (and communicating) person - Data and Details, Scientist / Technician.

The IJ's deficiency lies in the field of Motivations or Observations: typically he doesn't understand human nature and appreciate - or tolerate - human beings for being what they are. In popular culture, the IJ type can often appear to be ascetic, harsh and intolerant - which is why I call his shadow aspect the Mad Monk.

IV.

I think the Sellers system does a great job, not in the least in helping us understand the differences between the types. Keirsey lumps the ESTP and ISTP types in the same category - Artisan - and the pair share exactly the same functions: introverted thinking (Ti), extraverted sensing (Se), introverted intuition (Ni), extraverted feeling (Fe). If we're to go by the letters alone, the only difference appears in the letters at the start of each code - I for ISTP, E for ESTP. Yet both the ISTP and ESTP seem completely dissimilar, and no-one in their right minds would ever confuse the two when put side by side.




The disparity holds true despite the fact that each type shares primary and secondary functions - introverted thinking (primary in ISTP, secondary in ESTP) and extraverted sensing (secondary in ISTP, primary in ESTP). But both the ESTP and ISTP differ in their tertiary function, and this makes all the difference. The ESTP uses his tertiary function, extraverted feeling, Fe, to understand the universe (Principles), and does a good job of it. The ISTP, in contrast, uses Fe as a fourth and inferior function, and does a bad job of it - he has a difficult time grasping Principles. On the other hand, the ISTP has a fairly good grasp on Actions and Planning, which is the shortcoming of the ESTP type. That is, the ISTP effectively uses introverted intuition, Ni, in his default action role as Zen Warrior, but introverted intuition makes up the repressed, inferior function in the ESTP.

Rightly understood, the two leading functions - primary and secondary - lead in the front, while the tertiary sits in the back and helps. The fourth or inferior function acts - or can act - as a spoiler or disruptor. Jung sees it as the repressed 'unconscious' of the leading, dominant function.

Picking a character's type in the comic books necessitates a good working knowledge of MBTI and some skill. But generally, we'll have an easy time of it, because comic books use the same types, over and over again. Mr Fantastic's INTP turns up a lot, as does Darkseid's ENTJ and Judge Dredd's ISTJ. In both movies and comic books, we find Han Solo's ISTP used as a staple, and Taylor has drawn up a list of ISTPs as long as your arm. The conclusion to be drawn is that in order to determine a character's type, you only need to consult the database of existing types and ask yourself, 'Does this character resemble Judge Dredd in any way? Or Superman? Or the Joker?' and then match the character to that best-known example. Spiderman, Mister Fantastic, Doctor Manhattan, Sherlock Holmes, Sheldon from the TV show Big Bang Theory belong in the INTP category; chances are that any geeky, science-minded character like these five is an INTP.